|
Marketing is currently one of the most promising approaches
for accelerating sanitation coverage. The process of sanitation
marketing emerged from reflection, debate, and experimentation
around the question of how to stimulate sanitation demand
and increase coverage in a sustainable way. In fact, marketing
is at the core of the diffusion of innovations and the takeoff
of new consumer products in the modern world (Gatingon and
Robertson 1985). Cairncross (2004) discusses four arguments
for using the marketing approach for sanitation:
- It ensures that people choose to receive what they want
and are willing to pay for.
- It is financially sustainable.
- It is cost-effective and can be taken to scale.
- Provision of hardware is not enough. Marketing (with its
four component strategies) is a proven and highly effective
way to build demand.
Essentially, for sanitation managers in the public or NGO
sector, marketing sanitation means:
1) using a commercial approach to expand the supply chain
and market for the production and delivery of sanitation products,
and services
2) engaging and developing the private sector to undertake
production and delivery in a sustainable way. This includes
understanding and removing the constraints that prevent the
supply side working effectively
3) generating new demand through the application of consumer
science and the use of marketing techniques
It is important to appreciate that marketing is a multi-component
coordinated intervention that uses a variety of strategies
simultaneously to address the four core P’s of marketing
(Cairncross 2004; Methra 1998):
- Product – “Latrine designs must respond to what
people want, rather than what sanitation engineers believe
they should have.” Selling products and services without
subsidy is the most reliable way of knowing that the design
is right. Market research and consumer testing of new designs
prior to their launch is a critical part of the design process.
Often a range of different products is needed to suit different
household budgets and circumstances. Offering choice has been
a core strategy for success in many innovative approaches
to generating sanitation demand. The same principles apply
to service levels.
- Price – Most of those who need sanitation are poor
and can least afford it. Keeping down costs, reducing initial
outlay, and marketing a range of products at different price
tags is essential. Extreme low-cost product innovations can
release demand among the poor (Kar 2003).
- Place - Products must reach the right place. There must
be the potential for product supply chains, information and
services to reach every household. Examples of effective strategies
to increase sanitation access and opportunities to act include:
- Programmes that train local masons
- Door-to-door sales and promotion techniques
- Local centres or mobile services that offer a ‘One
Stop Shop’ for information, products and services
- Promotion – This includes communications, advertising
and sales techniques to present the product and service, and
to convince customers to buy. This task is vitally important
for building primary demand for new sanitation. Consumer science
and professional advertising and market communications skills
can be very valuable in developing effective promotional materials,
content, and strategies that work with consumers.
The private sector knows that to achieve takeoff in the pioneering
stages of a new product category, there are four essential
tasks to undertake:
- educate consumers about the new category
- encourage trial usage
- build the distribution channel
- segment the market to better serve specific needs (Haim
1997).
Thus, we need to rethink our use of sanitation investments.
More money, effort and creativity needs to be focussed on
consumer education and product promotion. Thus increased information
together with the development of commercial distribution for
improved and cheaper products, is needed to accelerate the
rate of uptake of improved sanitation.
In-depth studies of households who adopt improved sanitation
and those who do not, have confirmed the importance of four
programme design features needed to stimulate adoption and
new demand:
1) offering households a choice of locally adapted sanitation
products and service levels to suit their budgets and lifestyles
2) coupled with access to good information about technical,
functional, financial and construction features of the different
options,
3) using creative promotional communications strategies to
raise awareness, interest and motivation, and
4) using various door-to-door promotion techniques to directly
engage individual households.
Addressing the issue of construction without subsidy is a
crucial element for successful demand stimulation in many
projects, especially in rural areas (Jenkins 2004; Kar 2003;
Mukherjee 2000; Frias and Mukerjee 2005; WSP-Africa 2005).
Critics of the marketing process usually voice concerns about
how it neglects the needs of the poor. This ignores the fact
that current practices are failing to reach the poor. The
simple message when beginning a sanitation marketing process
is ‘don’t panic about the poor’. Marketing
is an on-going process which requires constant review and
redesign. It is important during the monitoring and evaluation
process to assess whether the poor, and other vulnerable groups,
are actually acquiring and using latrines and if they are
not, what constraints they are facing. If these can be recognised
then positive action can be taken to target and support them.
Designs of extremely affordable latrines; savings and loan
groups, or specially targeted informational efforts, are all
ways to address the needs of the poor. If they are acquiring
latrines and the market is meeting their needs then no action
is necessary. One of the basic principles behind marketing
is that of offering the consumer a choice. Choice is the one
thing the poor lack as their behaviour is dictated by the
circumstances in which they find themselves. By offering a
choice directly to the poor, the marketing approach can become
an empowering process.
|